He is also a notable proponent of analytical marxism, and a critic of neoclassical economics and public choice theory, largely on behavioral and. Definitions of rational choice there is no widely accepted definition of rational choice theory, but there are two important senses in which the term is used. It can inform understanding of both the authors choice and the. Elsters account was an exhaustive examination of marxs texts in order to ascertain what could be salvaged out of marxism employing the tools of rational choice theory and methodological individualism which elster defended as the only form of explanation appropriate to the social sciences. The present work is at the intersection of these two failures. It has long appeared to many people that economics is the most successful of the social sciences. Foundations of rational choice theory much of elsters work involves explication of the central assumptions of rational choice the ory.
Economists and decision theorists tend to adopt a thin and unnuanced conception of rationality, in which rational choice is strictly characterised by fixed preferences, cardinal utilities, subjectively construed. Sour grapes aims to subvert orthodox theories of rational choice through the sour grapes. Studies in the subversion of rationality jon elster. Gametheoretic marxism occurs in scott lash and john urry, the new marxism of collective. Studies in the subversion of rationality thirtyfive years after publication. Basic assumptions and approach to human social action1 rational choice is formulated in universalistic terms, abstracted to a large extent from historical and socio 1among the scholars in the social sciences, especially economics, who have contributed to. Many authors seem to value formal proofs of theories more than the con. Rationality and social exchange basic to all forms of rational choice theory is the assumption that complex social phenomena can. Pdf a critical discussion of jon elsters arguments. One of the pioneers of the rational choice theory has been gary becker. Rational choice theory and explanation frank lovett abstract much of the debate concerning rational choice theory rct is fruitless because many people both critics and defenders fail to correctly understand the role it plays in developing explanations of social phenomena. What are the main strengths and weaknesses of the rational choice approach to religions behavior. Theory of practice, rational choice, and historical change.
Elsters treatment of rational choice is fquite knowledgeable and sophisticated. Rational choice theory actually consists of a family of theories, usually but not always mathematical, that investigate the ways that actions taken by rational individual. The nature and scope of rationalchoice explanation. Although some of the bad arguments may apply to bad versions of the theory, critics ought to address the best versions. Download rational choice in an uncertain world in pdf and epub formats for free. The aim of rational choice theory is to prescribe what it is rational for an agent to do in a given situation and to explain the agents behavior by the hypothesis that he or she follows the prescription.
It becomes possible to grant individual 7 analytical marxism is the title that appears to have been chosen by the leading exponents them selves. For the most part, people view rational choice theory as a species of intentional explanation. September 2004 1 individual decisionmaking individual decisionmaking forms the basis for nearly all of microeconomic analysis. He states that this approach can be applied to all human behaviour, including religion. Elster interpretation and rational choice 3 information. Elster continues to hold rational choice theory in high esteem, as providing insight into some of the nuts and bolts of human behavior.
Sour grapes aims to subvert orthodox theories of rational choice through the study of forms of irrationality. In an article written in 1977 the author offered a survey of unresolved problems in rational choice theory. He states that this approach can be applied to all human behaviour, includingreligion. The overall approach exhibits three main characteristics. Rational choice theory an overview sciencedirect topics. Rational choice theory and explanation frank lovett, 2006. Theory of practice, rational choice, and historical change ivan ermakoff published online. The nature and scope of rationalchoice explanation springerlink. Rational choice theory is a general theory of action and is considered as one of the three overarching metatheoretical paradigms in the social sciences, with structuralinstitutional. But he presents the theory in a manner that renders it empirically incorrect, and gives no way to improve upon it, except to talk about emotions and irrationality.
Some unresolved problems in the theory of rational behavior. He is also a notable proponent of analytical marxism, and a critic of neoclassical economics and public choice theory, largely on behavioral and psychological grounds. At least in specific domains of theory, rationalchoice marxism opens up the third, transcendent box. Dr elster begins with an analysis of the notation of rationality, to provide the background and terms for the subsequent discussions, which cover irrational behaviour, irrational desires and irrational belief. Pdf on sep 1, 2000, jon elster and others published rational choice history. Many marxists who took no part in its initiation have become converts, while those who continue to criticise it nevertheless tend to treat it respectfully. Introduction to choice theory jonathan levin and paul milgrom. Kolbeinn stefansson rated it it was amazing nov 06, of course, we should note that this whole dynamic changes where there is the prospect of repeated interactions between alice and bob.
Many rational choice theorists evidently believe that no theory could simultaneously describe be havior better than, and be as rigorous as, rational choice theory. Pdf rational choice theory and explanation researchgate. The deterrent is globally maximizing or so it is postulated. What are the main strengths and weaknesses of the rational. A critical discussion of jon elsters arguments about rational choice, infinite regress and the collection of information. Not all sociological reservations about rational choice derive from misunderstanding, however. The success and failure of rational choice 3 given all this, it can be said without great controversy that no other theoretical approach in this century has ever enjoyed the same level of ubiquity throughout the social sciences as the rational choice approach enjoys today.
Much of the debate concerning rational choice theory rct is fruitless because many people both critics and defenders fail to correctly understand the role it plays in developing explanations. In order to understand this notion, elster uses a transdisciplinary perspective that aims to fill this gap in the assumptions of standard rational choice. It assumes that people engage in maximising behaviour. Pdf on apr 1, 1999, hans o melberg and others published a critical discussion of jon elster s arguments about rational choice, infinite regress and the collection of information find, read and.
A critical discussion of jon elster s arguments about rational choice, infinite regress and the collection of information. What are the main strengths and weaknesses of the rational choice approach toreligions behavior. Dr elster begins with an analysis of the notation of rationality, to provide the background and terms for the subsequent discussions, which cover irrational. Elster argues that marxs chief arguments are generally compatible with a rationalchoice model of explanation, and that the relevant microfoundations may be constructed on the basis of rationalchoice analysis of the choices made by participants within the context of the institutions of capitalism. Rational choice theory and bounded rationality1 till gr. Auto suggestions are available once you type at least 3 letters. Rationalchoice theorists deny that it is see hechter 1996. The interpretation of fiction benefits from the use of this type of explanation.
Furthermore, the theory must prescribe which beliefs it is rational for the agents to hold, given their evidence or information. Pdf download rational choice in an uncertain world free. Interpretation and rational choice jon elster, 2009 sage journals. Rational choice theory has been successfully applied in many disciplines of the social sciences to model and understand behavior as diverse as consumer choice, managerial decision making, career choice, criminal behavior, and financial investments, to name just a few becker and becker, 1997. At the same time, the critical voices against it are increasing in volume. The aim of rationalchoice theory is to prescribe what it is rational for an agent to do in a given situation and to explain the agents behavior by the hypothesis that he or she follows the prescription. It would, however, be a mistake to think that elster wants to replace rational.
The rational choice theory and mexican drug activity. Nov 07, 2019 sour grapes aims to subvert orthodox theories of rational choice through the sour grapes. Elster argues that marxs chief arguments are generally compatible with a rational choice model of explanation, and that the relevant microfoundations may be constructed on the basis of rational choice analysis of the choices made by participants within the context of the institutions of capitalism. A prominent theorist in the field of rational choice and decision making, jon elster develops a rich selection of empirical examples and case studies to demonstrate the diversity of procedures used by institutions that mete out local justice. It has been argued that rational choice theory should explain actors actions as well. The topic of this article, the relation between emotion and rationality, is a more recent concern, reflecting the fact that the idea of rationality is itself a fairly new one. The relation between emotion and reason has been a major topic in western philosophy since its inception.
Nothing is easier for passion than to overcome reason, but its greatest triumph is to conquer a mans own interest. These notes outline the standard economic model of rational choice in decisionmaking. Interpretation and rational choice jon elster, 2009. Real behavior, they seem to believe, is too chaotic to be rigorously accounted for with any precision. Debate concerning rct can progress in a worthwhile manner only once this point is correctly understood. Rational choice theory rational choice theory john scott from understanding contemporary society. Research interests include theory of rational choice and the theory of distributive justice. Elster wrote numerous books attempting to use rational choice theory for a wide variety of social.
Rational choice theory is often criticized, sometimes with good arguments, and sometimes with bad. Rational choice explanation plays a critical role in the interpretation of both texts and social behavior. Introduction rational choice theory rct has dominated economics for more than 50 years, and it is becoming increasingly important in other socialscience disciplines. On the other hand, there is the still more recent idea of rational choice, which. Jon elster daniel little new horizons in economic thought.
Elster begins with an analysis of the notation of rationality, before tackling the notions of irrational behavior, desires and belief with highly sophisticated arguments that. Elster s treatment of rational choice is fquite knowledgeable and sophisticated. Ulysses and the sirens studies in rationality and irrationality. For earlier arguments along the same lines see elster 2000 and elster 2007, notably. Rational choice theory assumes agents have a subjective prior over the effect of their choices on. The purpose of rational choice theory is to explain social phenomena by assuming rational choice at the actors level coleman, 1990. Rational choice marxism originated as a distinct school of thought in the 1970s and grew rapidly during the 1980s. Rational choice theory socorro independent school district. Above all, rational choice is a theorydriven enterprise. Jan 01, 1986 jon elster born 22 february 1940, oslo is a norwegian social and political theorist who has authored works in the philosophy of social science and rational choice theory. Jon elster born 22 february 1940, oslo is a norwegian social and political theorist who has authored works in the philosophy of social science and rational choice theory. A case of excessive ambition find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate.
Foundations of rational choice theory much of elster s work involves explication of the central assumptions of rational choice the ory. Despite this ubiquity, the success of the approach has been very tenuous. Furthermore, according to elster, rational choice has failed to explain the extremely relevant reasons behind the comprehension of human behaviour. Elster begins with an analysis of the notation of rationality, before tackling the notions of irrational behavior, desires and belief with highly sophisticated arguments that subvert the orthodox theories of rational choice. Minimally, rational choice theory must tell the agents how best to realize their desires, given their beliefs. I demonstrate that many critiques of rational choice theory have been misguided, since instrumental rationalitythe rationality of rational choice theoryis applicable to a wide variety of social situations, including situations where various psychological, informational, and structural factors claimed to interfere with rational decision. Pdf a critical discussion of jon elsters arguments about. Emotional choice and rational choice oxford handbooks. Interpretation and rational choice arcade stanford.
1052 166 592 1559 360 1225 380 637 130 74 416 180 969 297 846 757 478 1348 1380 185 269 29 1206 1032 1235 331 788 995 1104 1451 613 360 649 470 1066 330 65 846 383 1229